Customer Impact

Bureau kiezen

How to choose a marketing agency that fits your business

Copy for AI

Start with your goal and your budget, not with the agency’s pitch.

That’s how to choose a marketing agency that fits. Then decide per discipline whether you need a specialist or one team.

The verdict: the right agency proves results with a client, a figure and a period, and leaves your accounts and data in your name. Compare three proposals on the same six points.

Choosing a good marketing agency starts with your own goal.

Maybe your current agency is disappointing. Or there are three proposals on the table that you can’t line up side by side.

Choose on price or a slick pitch, and the accounts often end up in the agency’s name.

Switching then costs you months, and sometimes your advertising history.

You’ll find agency names in our overview of the best digital marketing agency.

Where do you start when choosing a marketing agency?

On paper, before you call a single agency.

Make 5 choices first. That way you later compare answers instead of impressions.

Step 1: set your goal

Do you want more enquiries, more revenue from your online store or a stronger brand?

Pick one as your main goal.

Step 2: choose your KPI

Define what you’ll hold the agency to: qualified leads, pipeline or revenue.

Visitors and impressions are supporting metrics. Our list of lead generation KPIs helps you pick.

Step 3: fix your budget

Split the agency fee from the media budget.

You’ll immediately see who counts ad spend as their own revenue.

Step 4: decide what stays in-house

Who writes, who approves, who follows up leads?

An agency fills gaps. It doesn’t replace sales.

Step 5: make a shortlist of three

Fewer gives no comparison. More gives superficial conversations.

Still torn between an agency, a freelancer or your own team? Then first read agency vs freelancer vs in-house.

Our experience: when a prospect asks us for one channel, we first ask why. Sometimes the real need is a migration or better keyword research, not the channel they named.

Specialist or full service: which marketing agency to choose per discipline?

There’s no general answer. It depends on how strongly the disciplines lean on each other.

Rule of thumb: choose a specialist for deep technical work, and one team where channels decide each other’s results.

DisciplineChoose a specialist ifChoose one team ifGuide
SEOyou are doing a technical migration or rebuilding a large siteSEO and content need to bring in leads togetherchoosing an SEO agency
Google Adsyou want a large Shopping or e-commerce account steered purely on ROASads, landing pages and conversion need to work togetherchoosing a Google Ads agency
Contentyou only need copycontent needs to rank and convertcontent marketing agency
Brandingyou need a complete new identity with a studiobrand and website need to sell togetherchoosing a branding agency
Websiteyou are building a complex web applicationthe site mainly needs to generate leadschoosing a web design agency
AI visibility (GEO)you only want an auditGEO needs to build on your SEO and contentchoosing a GEO agency
Lead generationyou mainly want outbound call volumeseveral channels need to fill the pipeline togetherchoosing a lead generation agency
Growthyou only need product experiments (onboarding, pricing)you want to adjust the whole funnel continuouslychoosing a growth marketing agency
Social mediayou are looking for organic community management and daily postsyou want to link B2B ads on LinkedIn and Meta to your lead flowbest social media agency

Two cases where one team won

At Facilicom, Google Ads, content writing and landing pages together delivered 25% media savings.

At A.F.Vandevorst, Google Ads, Facebook, CRO and email together delivered +164% online revenue growth.

In both, the result came from channels working together, not from one channel alone.

Which questions should you ask a marketing agency?

Ask these 10 questions in every intake meeting, in the same order.

Write down the answers word for word.

  1. Which case resembles my situation, with client, figure and period?
  2. Who actually does the work, and do I get to speak with that person myself?
  3. Are my Google Ads, Analytics and Search Console accounts in my name?
  4. How long is the minimum term, and what is the notice period?
  5. Which KPI do you report every month, and from which source?
  6. Do you report pipeline from my CRM, or only form fills?
  7. What happens in the first thirty days?
  8. What is agency fee and what is media budget?
  9. What do you not promise?
  10. Do you track whether AI assistants such as ChatGPT mention my company?

Question 9 is the litmus test

Google itself writes: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google” (Google Search Central).

Here’s that line on Google’s own page. Look at the warning about guarantees:

Google Search Central guidance on hiring an SEO stating that no one can guarantee a number 1 ranking on Google, the guarantee test when choosing a marketing agency Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO, October 2026: no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and a guarantee of first place is a reason to look elsewhere.

Google also recommends asking for examples of previous work.

Anyone who still gives guarantees is on our list of red flags at a marketing agency.

Question 3: who owns your accounts?

You should be the administrator yourself.

In Google Ads only that role can “grant account access, change access levels” (Google Ads Help).

Read more in who owns your Google Ads account.

Our experience: with us, the client owns everything: content, links and accounts.

Question 7: what a good first month looks like

A good answer is concrete. Ours starts with a baseline:

  • connect Google Analytics, Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools
  • start measuring visibility in AI Overviews and AI assistants
  • translate your goals into KPIs and the indicators we monitor

A vague “we’ll get to know your business” isn’t an answer.

Question 10: AI visibility

If buyers ask ChatGPT for a shortlist, you want to be on it. So ask how the agency measures whether you appear.

How that works is in what AI visibility is.

Using AI to find agencies? Read which marketing agencies AI recommends and why first: the names shift by tool and by attempt.

How do you recognise real proof in cases and references?

By how precisely it’s shown. Every agency says it delivers results.

A logo on a slide isn’t proof. Neither is a percentage without a period.

Look at the type of figure

Visitors are an intermediate step. MQLs and revenue are the goal.

Take the SEO case of Gom Nederland and the ABM case of Facilicom as examples.

Call one reference yourself

Ask for one reference you may call.

Ask what went wrong, and how the agency responded.

Watch out: an agency that can’t name anything that went wrong gives you nothing to judge.

How do you compare three proposals fairly?

Every agency uses its own format. So line proposals up side by side on the same 6 points:

CriterionWhat you should see
ScopeConcrete deliverables per month, not “everything around SEO”
Fee vs mediaAgency fee and media budget separate, no hidden commission
TeamNames and roles of the people doing the work
ContractMinimum term, notice period and review point
KPIOne main KPI that matches your goal
ExitAccounts, data and content remain yours

Here’s how that looks with three example proposals:

COMPARISON MODEL Three proposals, six criteria Proposal A Proposal B Proposal C Scope✓✓✗ Fee vs media✗✓✓ Team✓✓✗ Contract✓✓✓ KPI✗✓✓ Exit✗✓✗ Example for illustration. An ✗ on exit weighs more than a lower price.
Three proposals compared on six criteria. The cheapest proposal is rarely the one that holds up on every point.

Pay particular attention to the contract

A long term without a review point is a risk.

How to get out of one is in stuck in a contract with your marketing agency.

Decision rule: if two proposals tie, pick the one with the cleaner exit.

What changes if you are a B2B company?

In B2B a sales cycle lasts weeks to months.

A form fill isn’t yet a customer. An agency that only counts form fills is steering on the wrong number.

So ask whether the agency takes lead quality and pipeline from your CRM into account.

From form fill to customer

Lifecycle stages make that difference visible. Look at how a lead moves through MQL and SQL before it becomes a customer:

HubSpot lifecycle stages from subscriber and lead to MQL, SQL, opportunity and customer, the pipeline stages a B2B marketing agency should report on HubSpot’s lifecycle stage definitions, checked 18 October 2026.

A good agency reports on the later stages, not only on the first one.

How that link works in practice is in offline conversions in Google Ads.

Working on a long B2B buying journey? Then also see our overview of the best B2B lead generation agency in Belgium.

What a client told us

One of our clients described the difference like this:

“We had another agency that wanted to sign us straight away. Here we get confronted with the facts, and that is worth more to us than: sure, give me your money and we will just try something.”

Jordi, Elysium Journeys

When we are not the right choice

  • Organic social media management: we run B2B ads on social, not daily community work. Choose a social media agency.
  • A big brand campaign with TV, print or events: an advertising or full service communications agency fits better.
  • Consumer sales with thousands of products online: an e-commerce specialist is then often a better fit.
  • Loose hours on your instructions: a freelancer is simpler and cheaper.

Does your request fit us? Tell us your goal and we’ll tell you honestly whether we’re the right match.

Frequently asked questions

What does a marketing agency cost per month?

That depends on scope and channels, and media budget always comes on top. With us, SEO starts at 2,450 euros per month and content at 950 euros per month, with a three-month minimum. You can find all the amounts in what a marketing agency costs.

Is a large or small marketing agency better for an SME?

A small senior team is often faster, and you work directly with the people doing the work. A large agency has more capacity if you want to run many channels at once.

How many agencies should you ask for a proposal?

Three is enough. That way you can compare without only half-reading each proposal.

How long should you sign for?

Choose a contract with a clear minimum term and a review after three months. With us the minimum term is three months, with no setup fee.

Free website scan

Enter your website and get an automatic scan within minutes, with concrete technical and SEO improvements. No sales pitch.

Where should we send your report?

We only use your details for your scan. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.