Customer Impact

Data & Tracking

Matomo vs GA4: when to choose privacy-friendly analytics (and where Piwik PRO fits)

Copy for AI

Matomo is open-source analytics and the best-known alternative to Google Analytics 4.

The big difference: with Matomo you own your data. Reports aren’t sampled, and you can keep the data in the EU or on your own server.

The verdict: pick GA4 when Google Ads drives your leads, Matomo when data ownership matters most. Many B2B companies run both.

GA4 is free and stronger once you advertise with Google Ads. Audiences, conversions and modelling run straight through the Google ecosystem.

So the choice comes down to one question: what weighs more, data sovereignty or ad steering?

This guide compares Matomo and GA4 on the points that matter for Belgian and Dutch companies. Piwik PRO, the third tool that often makes the shortlist, gets its own section.

How GA4 itself works is in our guide to GA4. The privacy side of GA4 is in is Google Analytics GDPR compliant.

What is Matomo?

Matomo, formerly Piwik, is a web analytics platform you can use in two ways.

Matomo On-Premise

You install Matomo on your own server.

The community edition is free, with no limit on users or hits. You do pay for hosting, maintenance and updates.

Watch out: “free” here means free software, not free running costs. Someone has to patch that server.

Matomo Cloud

Matomo hosts it for you.

Price: according to Matomo’s pricing page (checked 5 November 2026), Cloud starts at 29 euro per month for 50,000 hits, excluding tax.

Hosting: the data is stored in Frankfurt, Germany.

That’s the vendor’s price, not ours. Our guide to EU hosting and GDPR data residency explains why the location matters.

What Matomo measures

Everything you expect from an analytics tool:

  • visits, sources and pages
  • goals, events and funnels
  • ecommerce

It also has its own Tag Manager. Or you load Matomo through Google Tag Manager, if that’s where you manage all your tags.

Matomo vs GA4: the comparison

Matomo wins on ownership and sampling; GA4 wins on Google Ads and price at scale.

Here’s the full picture:

MatomoGoogle Analytics 4
Data ownerYou (on-premise) or you via Matomo Cloud in the EUGoogle
PriceOn-Premise free (hosting not), Cloud paidFree (360 paid for enterprise)
SamplingNo sampling, reports on the full datasetSampling in certain explorations on large datasets
RetentionYour choice2 or 14 months for user data (standard)
Google Ads connectionLimited, no native audiences or modellingNative: audiences, conversion import, Consent Mode modelling
Cookieless measurementConfigurableThrough Consent Mode (cookieless pings, modelling)
Learning curveFamiliar reports, resembles old Universal AnalyticsEvent model, needs more setup

Three of those rows deserve a closer look.

Sampling

Matomo states that every report comes from the full dataset. GA4 works with a sample in certain advanced analyses above large thresholds.

For most B2B sites with limited traffic, sampling in GA4 hardly matters. For large sites or long periods, it does.

More on this in data sampling in Google Analytics.

Retention

A standard GA4 property lets you keep user data for 2 or 14 months.

Want year-on-year comparisons at user level? Then you hit that limit, unless you export to BigQuery. In Matomo, you decide how long you keep data.

Here’s how the retention limits compare across the three tools in this guide:

DATA RETENTION How long you keep user data GA4 (standard) 14 months max Piwik PRO Business 25 months Matomo your choice Sources: Google Analytics help, Piwik PRO pricing page (5 November 2026); Matomo retention is your own setting. GA4 can also keep data for 2 months; a BigQuery export keeps raw data longer.

So if long-term user history matters, GA4 needs an export; Matomo doesn’t.

This is the deciding row for anyone who advertises.

GA4 audiences for remarketing, the link between GA4 and Google Ads and conversion modelling under Consent Mode v2 don’t exist in Matomo.

If Matomo is your only tool, you steer Google Ads on the Google Ads conversion tag alone.

Here’s the kind of GA4 report you’d give up, from our own property:

GA4 traffic acquisition report for customerimpact.be filtered on one source, the Google Analytics side of a Matomo vs GA4 comparison GA4 Traffic acquisition in our own property, last 90 days, October 2026: 58 sessions from chatgpt.com.

Matomo shows sources too. What it can’t do is feed those visitors back into Google Ads as an audience.

Only where the law allows it, and only with a strict setup.

It’s the argument you hear most often, and it’s more nuanced than it sounds.

What Matomo itself says

Matomo says you can measure without consent only if the applicable law allows it, and only with a strict configuration:

  • cookies off and IP addresses anonymised
  • no personal data in URLs or events, and no User ID
  • an opt-out on offer
  • the data used for analysis only

Matomo names countries such as France and the Netherlands where such exemptions exist. It warns that consent stays mandatory elsewhere for client-side analytics.

What it means in Belgium

The position of the Data Protection Authority is clear: analytics cookies aren’t strictly necessary in principle. So they need prior consent.

Planning to measure cookieless without a banner? Run it past your DPO or lawyer.

We give you the technical setup, not legal advice. Also read cookie banner rules in Belgium and our guide to cookieless marketing.

And Piwik PRO?

Piwik PRO is the paid, all-in-one cousin: analytics, tag manager, CMP and CDP in one suite.

It shares its origins with Matomo, but it’s a separate commercial product. It targets organisations with strict rules on privacy and hosting, such as healthcare, government and financial services.

Piwik PRO pricing

Following old forum advice? Things have changed.

According to Piwik PRO’s pricing page (checked 5 November 2026):

  • Free plan: none any more, only a 30-day trial
  • Price: the Business plan starts at €36 per month
  • Volume: up to 2 million actions per month, across up to 20 domains
  • Retention: 25 months
  • Hosting: EU cloud servers in Sweden

Enterprise plans cost more. Again, these are the vendor’s prices.

Three tools side by side

MatomoPiwik PROGA4
ModelOpen source, self-host or cloudCommercial suite (cloud)Free SaaS from Google
Free optionOn-Premise community edition30-day trialYes
Built-in CMPNoYesNo (external CMP needed)
Strong inOwn data, simplicityRegulated sectors, suiteAd steering, free at scale

Which one do you choose? A decision guide

Answer four questions, in this order.

1. Do you advertise with Google Ads or Performance Max?

Then keep GA4, at least for audiences and conversions.

You can run Matomo or Piwik PRO alongside it for your own, complete picture of the website.

2. Are you in a regulated sector, or may data not leave the EU?

Then Matomo On-Premise or Piwik PRO is the logical main tool.

3. Do you mainly want simple reports and advertise little?

Then Matomo Cloud is often the quickest choice, without depending on Google.

4. Running both?

Make sure they use the same events and definitions. Otherwise you’re comparing apples with oranges.

A shared data layer in GTM is the foundation for that; see event tracking.

For example, say a SaaS company runs Google Ads and also wants two years of history. GA4 steers the ads; Matomo keeps the long view.

Your CRM stays the source of truth

In every scenario, your CRM holds the truth on leads and revenue.

Analytics tells you how visitors move. Your CRM tells you who became a customer.

How to connect the two is in how to set up lead tracking.

Common mistakes when switching

Four mistakes cost the most, and two of them hit your ad budget directly.

  • Switching off GA4 while Google Ads relies on it: audiences and imported conversions vanish
  • Loading Matomo twice: a WordPress plugin plus a GTM tag doubles your visits
  • No consent connection: Matomo with cookies must also wait for your banner
  • Expecting the numbers to match: two tools count visits differently

On consent: with Cookiebot you connect Matomo to your banner through GTM.

On matching numbers: session definitions, bot filters and consent all differ. Compare trends, not absolute numbers.

How do you check that it works?

Click through your site with Matomo’s real-time report open, then test consent and compare with your CRM.

Step 1: Watch the Visits Log

Open Matomo’s real-time report (Visits Log) and click through your site. Every page and every goal should appear.

Here’s where you’ll find it:

GA4’s counterpart is the real-time report.

The Matomo tag should only fire after consent, or cookieless if that’s your choice.

Google Tag Assistant shows which tags fired and when.

Step 3: Compare after a week

Compare the number of leads in Matomo, GA4 and your CRM.

Big differences point to a setup error, not to a “better” tool.

Need help choosing or setting it up?

We set up GA4 and Matomo, and often the combination.

At Kaizo we built the full chain around GA4, Google Ads and Meta; read Kaizo’s setup.

With a tracking audit, we look at what you measure today and which tool fits. For the build itself, there’s our tracking specialist. Pricing on request.

For more on privacy-friendly measurement, read our guide to third-party cookies.

Frequently asked questions

Is Matomo free?

Matomo On-Premise (the community edition) is free to use; you do pay for your own server and maintenance. Matomo Cloud is paid, with a free trial.

Is Matomo better than Google Analytics?

Not in general. Matomo is better for data ownership, no sampling and EU hosting. GA4 is better for the Google Ads connection and is free at scale. For many companies, the combination is the answer.

Is Matomo GDPR compliant?

Matomo can be set up in a GDPR-compliant way, especially on-premise or with EU hosting. Compliance depends on your configuration and your consent flow, not on the tool alone.

What is the difference between Matomo and Piwik PRO?

Both come from the same project. Matomo stayed open source; Piwik PRO became a commercial suite with analytics, tag manager, CMP and CDP, aimed at regulated sectors.

Can I install Matomo through Google Tag Manager?

Yes. You load Matomo as a tag in Google Tag Manager, on a trigger that respects the visitor’s consent.

Free website scan

Enter your website and get an automatic scan within minutes, with concrete technical and SEO improvements. No sales pitch.

Where should we send your report?

We only use your details for your scan. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.