SEO
Soft 404 Errors: How to Spot and Fix Them
Copy for AI
A soft 404 is an error page that tells Google “everything is fine”.
The visitor sees “Nothing found” or “Product unavailable”.
Your server sends status code 200, which means: this page exists, feel free to index it.
The verdict: a soft 404 is a signal problem, not a design problem. Fix it per URL with the right status code, and Google stops wasting time on empty pages.
That mismatch between what you show and what you signal is one of the quieter indexation problems. Below: how to spot it, why it holds back your SEO, and how to fix it for good.
What exactly is a soft 404?
It’s a page that is an error in content, yet returns a 200 “OK” code to the browser and to Google.
Status codes in 30 seconds
Every time a browser or search engine requests a page, your server answers with a status code. It’s an invisible number that says what’s going on:
| Code | What it tells Google | Use it when |
|---|---|---|
| 200 | The page exists and is fine | The page has real content |
| 301 | Moved permanently to another URL | Content lives on elsewhere |
| 404 | This page doesn’t exist (anymore) | The page is gone |
| 410 | Deliberately and permanently removed | The page is gone on purpose |
Our guide to HTTP status codes for SEO covers the rest of the family, such as 302 and 503.
Where the “soft” comes in
A soft 404 arises when the content says “error” while the code says 200.
Google’s documentation on HTTP status codes describes it as a 2xx response whose content suggests an error, an empty page or an error message.
The visitor sees “no results” or an empty product page.
Google notices the mismatch and labels the URL a “soft 404” in Search Console.
The word “soft” refers to its ambiguous nature. It isn’t a real error page, but it isn’t a full page either.
That ambiguity is the problem.
A soft 404 isn’t a “real” 404
An ordinary 404 is honest: the page doesn’t exist, and the server says so.
A soft 404 is dishonest.
So you clean it up yourself. Don’t wait for Google.
Why do wrong status codes undermine your indexation?
Because every 200 is a promise to Google that the URL deserves a place in the index.
Google crawls your site with a limited budget of time and attention. Give dozens or hundreds of empty pages a 200 each, and three things happen:
- You waste crawl budget on URLs with nothing to index.
- You dilute your quality signal with thin pages posing as real ones.
- You muddy your index, so empty URLs compete with pages that earn leads.
Crawl budget: mostly a large-site problem
Google’s crawl budget guide warns that soft 404 pages “will continue to be crawled, and waste your budget”.
That mostly bites on large sites.
Google’s rough marks: 1 million+ pages, or 10,000+ pages that change daily.
There, it slows how quickly new content gets picked up. Our explainer on crawl budget shows how to tell whether you’re in that group.
Quality and index hygiene matter for every site
A site full of thin or empty pages that pose as full pages looks weaker to visitors and search engines alike.
For example, say a webshop with 2,000 real products also serves 6,000 empty filter combinations with a 200.
Google now sees a site that’s mostly empty. That’s index bloat in its purest form.
The reverse mistake is just as harmful
A page that works perfectly but accidentally gets a 404 or a noindex disappears from the index too.
Valuable content then drops out without you noticing.
Wrong codes go both ways. Both cost you visibility.
It ties in closely with how indexing your website plays out in practice: the right code is the condition to be picked up correctly at all.
How do you spot a soft 404?
Fastest in Google Search Console: Google lists every URL it labelled as a soft 404.
Step 1: Open the Page indexing report
In the Page indexing report, “Soft 404” is one of the reasons in the “Why pages aren’t indexed” table.
Click the row to see exactly which URLs Google flagged.
It’s Google telling you where the signal and the content don’t match:
New to the report? Our walkthrough of the Search Console indexing report explains every reason in that table.
Step 2: Check the status code yourself
Call up a page you know should be empty or broken. Then look at the returned code:
- via URL inspection in Google Search Console
- via a browser extension that shows the response code
- via the redirect checker for a batch of URLs at once
If you get a 200 on an error page, you have a hit.
Step 3: Watch the typical sources
Some page types are classic soft 404 factories:
- empty internal search results
- sold-out or removed products
- filtered category pages with no results
- expired offers and old event pages
Watch out: single-page apps that render “not found” with JavaScript often return a 200 for every URL.
Step 4: Run a technical audit
A tool that crawls your entire site exposes patterns: whole series of empty URLs that all send a 200.
Our technical website audit checklist shows what else that crawl should cover.
How Google itself spends its visits on your site shows up in the crawl stats in Search Console. The breakdown by response tells you which codes Googlebot actually receives:
Crawl Stats in our own Search Console for customerimpact.be, October 2026. The breakdown by response shows how many requests hit a 200, a 301 or a 404.
A soft 404 hides inside the “OK (200)” share.
So find the URLs in Page indexing, not here.
How do you fix soft 404s, step by step?
Decide per URL what it should be, then send the one code that matches.
There’s no button that fixes everything at once. Work URL by URL, or per pattern, through this decision:
1. The page should exist and have value
Then the empty or broken content is the real problem.
Fill the page with real content and make sure the server sends a clean 200.
For example: a category page that accidentally loads empty, or a product without a description.
2. The page is permanently gone
Then let the server return a real 404 or 410. That’s honesty, not weakness.
Google drops the URL from the index and gradually crawls it less often. For Google Search, the choice between the two barely matters: Google states that all 4xx errors except 429 are treated the same.
Rule of thumb: pick one of the two for your whole site and stick with it.
3. The content has moved or been replaced
Then set up a 301 redirect to the most relevant existing page.
Don’t send everything blindly to your homepage.
A visitor looking for a specific product gets nothing from that, and the old URL’s relevance is lost.
Moving many URLs at once? Build a 301 redirect plan before you switch anything.
4. Sold-out products and empty filters
Decide deliberately, case by case:
- Temporarily sold out: keep it live (200) with a clear message and alternatives.
- Permanently discontinued: a 404, or a 301 to its successor.
- Empty filter combination: don’t link to it, or return a 404.
5. JavaScript sites: two extra options
Single-page apps can’t always change the server code per URL. Google’s JavaScript SEO basics give two ways out:
- a JavaScript redirect to a URL that returns a 404, such as
/not-found - a
noindexrobots meta tag added to the error page
How that tag works is in our guide to the meta robots tag. Rendering trade-offs are in client-side rendering and AI search.
6. Validate the fix in Search Console
Once the code is right, open the “Soft 404” row in the Page indexing report and click Validate fix.
Google then recrawls the flagged URLs. Expect days to weeks, not hours.
The craft lies in that choice per URL, not in a trick. It’s the same principle as with fixing redirect chains: every URL should send exactly one clear, honest signal, without detours.
How do status codes fit into your growth engine?
They’re the foundation: content and authority only pay off on a site that sends honest signals.
Repairing soft 404s isn’t a standalone technical chore. It’s maintenance on the foundation that your organic visibility rests on.
Honest signals get indexed faster
A site that sends honest signals is indexed faster and more completely.
It earns trust, not only with Google but also with AI search engines like ChatGPT and Perplexity.
Those systems read that same structure to decide what they cite.
Order before creativity
At Customer Impact, we don’t treat SEO as isolated technical fixes. It’s one layer of a growth engine.
Status codes, crawl budget and indexation are the foundation. On top of that we build content and authority that yield leads instead of vanity rankings.
The broader picture is in our guide to technical SEO. Want an experienced SEO specialist to review your technical foundation and seal the leaks? We’re here to help.
Rarely the only cause, often the easiest to miss
Wrong status codes are rarely the only cause of weak visibility. But they’re easy to miss.
They don’t demand creativity. They demand order.
That order is what separates a weak site from one that climbs steadily.
If your pages don’t appear at all, start with why your website isn’t showing on Google.
Do you suspect your site is sending wrong signals?
We track down soft 404s and other status code errors and choose the right fix per URL.
Contact us and within 24 hours you’ll hear where your biggest technical opportunities lie.
Free website scan
Enter your website and get an automatic scan within minutes, with concrete technical and SEO improvements. No sales pitch.
We only use your details for your scan. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.