Advertising
Quality Score and bidding: does QS still count with smart bidding?
Copy for AI
Yes, Quality Score still counts with smart bidding.
Smart bidding decides how high you bid.
But the auction still runs on Ad Rank, and the quality of your ads and landing page is a core part of that.
The verdict: smart bidding takes over your bid, not your relevance. Weak ads or a weak landing page still make every lead more expensive.
Strictly speaking, Google says the 1 to 10 Quality Score is a diagnostic tool, not an input in the auction.
The catch: it measures exactly the quality that Ad Rank does use.
The algorithm doesn’t take over your relevance, it builds on it. Below: what QS still drives, and where to focus.
This page is part of our overview of what SEA is, the fundamentals of search engine advertising.
What does smart bidding take over, and what not?
Smart bidding takes over the size of your bid.
It doesn’t take over the quality of your ad or your landing page.
The four smart bidding strategies
Smart bidding is the collective name for Google’s conversion-based bid strategies. Google lists four of them:
- Maximize conversions: as many conversions as your budget allows
- Target CPA: conversions at a set cost per action
- Target ROAS: conversion value at a set return on ad spend
- Maximize conversion value: the most value within your budget
Read the basics in our explanation of smart bidding, or the short version in the smart bidding wiki.
Bids set at auction time
The algorithm sets your bid at auction time, based on many signals. Google names, for example:
- device and physical location
- weekday and time of day
- remarketing lists
- the actual search query, not just the matched keyword
From those, it estimates how likely this click is to convert.
Not an autopilot
The misconception is that automated bidding is an autopilot that handles everything. It isn’t.
It’s a bidding machine.
It works with the building blocks you supply, such as your ad copy, your keywords and your landing page.
Your ad and your landing page help decide whether you’re shown at all, and at what price.
Weak input: feed it weak relevance and the algorithm has to bid harder for the same position.
You see that back in your cost per lead.
Here’s the split in one picture:
Rule of thumb: the algorithm only bids. Relevance is still your job.
How does the auction still work?
Every search for your keyword triggers an auction. Ad Rank decides the winner and the order, not your bid alone.
What goes into Ad Rank
According to Google’s Ad Rank documentation, Ad Rank combines six things:
- your bid
- the quality of your ads and landing page
- Ad Rank thresholds
- the competitiveness of the auction
- the context of the search
- the expected impact of your assets and other ad formats
That means a competitor with a lower bid but better relevance can rank above you.
Our comparison of Ad Rank vs Quality Score unpacks the difference.
Quality Score: the diagnosis
Quality Score is the diagnostic representation of those quality signals, not an auction input itself.
You see a number from 1 to 10 per keyword.
It’s built from three components, each rated above average, average or below average:
- Expected CTR: how likely it is that people click your ad compared to others.
- Ad relevance: how well your ad copy matches the search intent.
- Landing page experience: how relevant, fast and usable your destination page is.
Each rating compares your ad with other advertisers whose ads showed for the same search over the last 90 days (Google Ads Help).
Here’s where you switch those columns on:
Same formula, different bidder
Smart bidding changes nothing about this mechanism. The formula stays the same.
The algorithm uses the same Ad Rank formula as manual bidding.
The only difference is who sets the bid: you or the machine. The relevance signals under the hood stay identical.
Why does relevance keep driving your cost per lead?
Because better quality lowers what you pay for the same position.
This is the real reason QS also counts with smart bidding.
Better quality, lower CPCs
Better ad and landing page quality pushes down your cost per click.
You reach the same position with a lower effective bid.
Google’s words: higher quality ads can often lead to lower CPCs.
It adds that what you actually pay “is often less” than your bid.
A weak score does the opposite.
The algorithm has to bid more to stay in the running, and that extra cost multiplies across every click and every conversion.
A worked example
For example, say your ad relevance is below par because your ad group is built too broadly.
Here’s what happens next:
- smart bidding compensates by bidding harder on the queries that do convert
- it may still hit its target CPA
- but at a higher price than necessary
Improve the relevance and your effective click price drops. That leaves the algorithm budget to scale.
In short: the algorithm doesn’t fix your structure, it works around it.
Why B2B feels it more
For B2B lead generation this weighs even heavier.
Your audience is small, your search volumes are lower and every misplaced euro carries through.
B2B clicks are expensive to begin with. Keyword Planner shows how wide the range can be for one software keyword:
Keyword Planner for “seo tools”, United States, plan from 17 October 2026. Top-of-page bid: 4.54 euros (low range) to 25.88 euros (high range).
At 25.88 euros per click, a few percent difference in effective click price adds up fast.
Over a quarter, it’s a serious difference in the number of qualified enquiries.
That’s why relevance isn’t a technical footnote but a lever on your pipeline.
What should you measure instead?
Measure cost per qualified lead, then cost per deal. Don’t take Quality Score itself as a KPI.
Look at the components, not the number
That 1 to 10 number is a diagnostic tool, not a goal.
Steering on the score often means fighting symptoms instead of tackling causes.
Look at the three components separately, because they point you to the real action:
| Component at “below average” | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Ad relevance | Ad copy doesn’t match the keywords | Split your ad groups more tightly |
| Landing page experience | Page misses the ad’s promise | Speed, mobile use, match with the ad |
| Expected CTR | People don’t click | Test headlines and assets |
The landing page work lies outside Google Ads.
Our guide to landing page experience covers it, and ad relevance and expected CTR each have their own deep dive.
Our guide on reducing CPC in Google Ads shows how that relevance gain turns into a lower click price.
Feed the algorithm the right conversion
Smart bidding optimises towards the conversions you mark as primary.
So the goal you set decides what “a good click” means.
Our experience: we usually run one primary goal and one secondary goal. The primary is the booking, and the secondary goals are the drivers toward that booking.
Here’s how a primary action looks in an account:
The contact form conversion action in our own Google Ads account, October 2026. It’s set as primary, so campaigns optimise on real enquiries.
Our guide to primary vs secondary conversions explains the setup.
Watch out: smart bidding needs conversion tracking switched on. Google recommends judging results over longer periods with at least 30 conversions, or 50 for Target ROAS (Google Ads Help).
The KPI that really matters
The KPI that matters is cost per qualified lead, and ultimately cost per deal.
A higher Quality Score is a consequence of that, not a goal in itself.
Decision rule: improve your relevance and your cost per lead drops while your score rises along with it.
Steer on the one, and the other follows.
How do we look at Quality Score and smart bidding?
As parts of one growth engine, not as separate dials.
Relevance as the foundation
Paid search is our fast acquisition layer: paid traffic that buys pipeline, not clicks or ROAS vanity.
So we treat the relevance signals under QS as a foundation, not as a side issue.
Without that foundation, the algorithm bids against itself.
Measuring beyond the click
We also extend the measurement beyond the click.
With offline conversion tracking and lead-to-deal attribution, we see which keywords and ads actually generate revenue.
Why it matters: only then can smart bidding optimise towards what counts, instead of towards form submissions that never become deals.
Our guide to conversion tracking covers the basics.
Want this set up by an experienced google ads specialist?
We make sure your bid strategy and your relevance reinforce each other instead of working against each other.
In short
Quality Score still counts, even now that Google bids automatically.
Smart bidding sets the size of your bid.
The auction runs on Ad Rank as much as ever, with expected CTR, ad relevance and landing page experience at its core.
Decision rule: steer on the components behind the number, and measure success in cost per lead and cost per deal.
Want your Google Ads to steer on pipeline instead of clicks?
Get in touch and we’ll show you where your relevance and your bid strategy pull in different directions.
Free website scan
Enter your website and get an automatic scan within minutes, with concrete technical and SEO improvements. No sales pitch.
We only use your details for your scan. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.